Vaccination Mandates—An Old Public Health Tool Faces New Challenges

Vaccination Mandates—An Old Public Health Tool Faces New Challenges

Michelle Mello and colleagues write in this JAMA Network Viewpoint that civic values were eroded during the COVID-19 pandemic, creating a groundswell of resistance to vaccines that have been a bedrock principle of U.S. public health policy.
COVID vaccines Unsplash/Brano

The authority of states and localities to require vaccination is a bedrock principle of public health law. Since 1905, when the US Supreme Court upheld compulsory smallpox inoculations, there has been sustained judicial consensus that the Constitution “does not import an absolute right to be…wholly freed from restraint.” Otherwise, “organized society could not exist with safety to its members.” Until recently, objections to mandatory vaccinations were confined to a small minority of US residents. However, civic values eroded during the COVID-19 pandemic, creating a groundswell of resistance. With state legislatures now sharply limiting public health authority and a bevy of legal challenges mounted vaccination mandates—an old and highly effective public health tool—face legal uncertainty that only a few years ago seemed inconceivable.

Read Full Viewpoint

Read More

Health Affairs Podcasts Square
News

Rebalancing Public Health Powers and Individual Liberty in the Age Of COVID

Stanford's Michelle Mello and her colleague Lawrence O. Gostin at Georgetown University analyze the strains that public health emergency powers underwent during the pandemic, then propose reforms to modernize public health law. Mello then discusses the issue with Health Affairs' Editor-in-Chief Alan Weil for his "Health Podyssey" podcast.
cover link Rebalancing Public Health Powers and Individual Liberty in the Age Of COVID
Michelle Mello and Neel Guha
Commentary

ChatGPT and Physicians’ Malpractice Risk

In this JAMA Forum perspective, SHP's Michelle Mello, professor of health policy and of law, and Neel Guha, a Stanford Law School student and PhD candidate in computer science, write that medical advice from AI chatbots is not yet highly accurate, so physicians should only use these systems to supplement more traditional forms of medical guidance.
cover link ChatGPT and Physicians’ Malpractice Risk
Medical Mystery-Getty
Commentary

I Worried the COVID Vaccine Gave My Husband a Stroke. It Took a Year to Find the Truth

In this commentary in the San Francisco Chronicle, Stanford Health Policy's Michelle Mello — professor of health policy and professor of law — shares her personal account of the year-long struggle to diagnose her husband's autoimmune disease.
cover link I Worried the COVID Vaccine Gave My Husband a Stroke. It Took a Year to Find the Truth